American Capital Management, Inc. |
In surveying the financial events of the last year, 2009 will be remembered as one of the most spectacular years in memory due to a dramatic reversal of fortunes and sentiment during the year. Through March 6th, the S&P 500 index declined -26% and then subsequently rebounded +67% to close the year with a +26.5% total return. It was the quickest increase of this magnitude since 1935 and the seventh most volatile in the S&P 500’s history. A significant recovery seemed unlikely in March and reinforces the notion that timing the market is difficult. Fundamentally, the economy and corporate profitability improved sooner than expected. GDP growth in the fourth quarter is expected to be over 5%, but the consensus forecast last March called for a decline. Expectations for 2010 S&P 500 operating earnings are approaching $80 versus last June’s consensus of $69. In the third quarter, approximately 80% of companies in the S&P 500 reported earnings above expectations. The federal government invested $245 billion in banks via TARP and more than half has been repaid after 15 months with a profit for the government. The longest and deepest recession since the 1930’s has ended with a vigorous recovery and the probability of a double-dip recession appears low. We are leaving an extraordinary investment climate where macro factors greatly influenced all securities in the market and entering a more normal environment where growth, profitability, financial strength and valuations will be more important. We believe the intermediate-term outlook offers above-average appreciation potential based upon the growth of our underlying investments. There are risks that threaten the strength of the recovery and corresponding short-term price corrections may occur, but we view any correction as an opportunity to selectively add to equities based upon our constructive investment outlook. A summary of index returns through December 31, 2009 is as follows:
| Dow Jones Industrials | +22.6% |
Russell
2000 |
+27.2% |
| MSCI EAFE | +31.8% | S&P 500 | +26.5% |
| NASDAQ Composite | +45.3% | Wilshire 5000 | +26.5% |
The global economy is rebounding strongly from the worst worldwide recession since the 1930’s. World economic growth will exceed +4% in 2010 led by China with +9% growth and other industrializing nations, such as, Brazil, India, Korea and Singapore growing approximately 5-7%. The U.S. will lead the most developed economies with over +3% growth. Europe will experience moderate growth of +2% while Japan continues to struggle with persistent deflation and low growth. The massive worldwide fiscal and monetary initiatives have helped stimulate a self-reinforcing recovery, which will serve as a platform of strength to deal with higher government deficits and public debt levels. The American economy is experiencing a vigorous investment-led rebound supported by increases in capital spending, inventory rebuilding, residential investment and exports. For example, spending on business equipment, primarily technology related, is projected to increase +8% and residential investment expenditures +13% reversing the negative trends persistent over the last two years. Positively, these areas of previous weakness have stabilized and are improving and becoming sources of strength. Consumer spending increased +2% in the second half of 2009, which is healthier than previously expected, and is projected to continue at a similarly moderate pace in 2010. However, the consumer’s ability to spend is constrained by modest income growth, continued debt deleveraging, lower housing wealth and tight credit. Consumer credit outstanding continues to shrink at a -4% rate, which is historically unusual, but not unexpected given the high debt levels. Also, state and local government expenditures will be under pressure because of reduced tax receipts.
Productivity growth has been booming. Productivity grew at +6.9% and +8.2% annualized rates in the second and third quarters of 2009, respectively. These high growth rates reflect increasing output with lean employment levels due to massive job cuts. Downsizing has eliminated 5.5% of the workforce from its peak level in December 2007, the worst decline since the 1930’s. We expect productivity to return to more normal levels with growth of +2% over the next two years. Positively, corporate profits are increasing faster than previously expected with S&P 500 earnings expected to increase +30% in 2010. Historically, sharp increases in productivity combined with above average increases in profitability presage employment growth, potentially providing a missing element of the current recovery.
Payroll growth appears likely in 2010, but the lack of job growth remains a frequently cited weakness of the economy. The deterioration in the labor market has dramatically improved with average monthly payrolls declining by 69,000 in the fourth quarter versus 691,000 in the first quarter of 2009. Average weekly hours worked in manufacturing – a significant leading indicator – increased during the fourth quarter of 2009 for the first time in seven quarters. Importantly, business sentiment is improving with surveys suggesting businesses are planning for the future instead of hunkering down in fear – further evidence that the negative feedback loop is easing. Employment data are typically lagging indicators, so it is not unusual to see improvements in other aspects of the economy prior to job growth. Given the considerable slack in labor market, these emerging improvements may gradually reduce the unemployment rate from its current level of 10.1%. But the rate would be 16% if it included the 5.6 million people no longer receiving benefits or looking for work. If they decide to rejoin the labor force, the unemployment rate will remain high for some time. In addition, unemployment is being impacted by the decline in labor mobility to the lowest level since 1948 because the –29% decline in house prices left 25% of homeowners with mortgages below home values. More importantly, there is no place to move with weak employment trends throughout the country.
Over the intermediate-term, employment growth will be essential to strengthen the expansion because aggregate wages positively influence consumer spending and tax receipts for federal and state jurisdictions. Consumer spending is rebounding more strongly than early 2009 predictions, but its growth will likely increase more moderately than the total economy’s as the “shift to thrift” and deleveraging occurs. The federal budget deficit is about 10% of GDP – the highest since WWII – due to a +18% increase in government outlays and a –17% decrease in tax receipts for the fiscal year 2009 ending in September. More specifically, receipts from individuals and corporations fell -20% and -55%, respectively, which leaves corporate tax receipts at their 2003 levels. Clearly, rebounding corporate profits and expanding payrolls will augment the pro-cyclical process of increasing tax receipts, lessening the need for social insurance expenditures, decreasing the deficit and freeing up resources for debt-repayment. But we are concerned regarding the possibility of a “jobless recovery.”
Overall inflation was +2.7% in 2009, but core inflation (ex. food and energy) was +1.8% reflecting few underlying pressures. Energy and commodity prices suppressed inflation below core in the early part of 2009, but accelerated in the second half of the year. Core inflation is expected to remain below +2% for 2010. The longer-term outlook for inflation is hotly debated with divergent views and significant consequences. Simply, the high inflation corner points to significant growth in the monetary base caused by the Fed’s stimulative policies and expansionary government policies which may result in too much money chasing too few goods. Low inflation proponents point to considerable slack in labor availability, industrial capacity, rental vacancy rates and the dependence on low priced imports for consumer goods. We believe low inflation will persist over the next two years, but acknowledge the fear of higher inflation warrants vigilant attention. The University of Michigan’s survey of inflationary expectations remains below +3%. Overall, inflation is subdued and likely to remain low for the foreseeable future due to low income growth, excess capacity and intense worldwide competitive pressures. Deflation remains a risk, but is unlikely to grip the U.S. at this time.
Currently,Federal Reserve policy remains accommodative with the federal funds rate lessthan one-quarter percent, but the tightening process has subtly begun with theFed ending most of its emergency liquidity facilities during the first quarterof 2010 and concluding the purchase of $1.25 trillion of mortgage-backedsecurities and $175 billion of agency debt by March 31, 2010.
The opportunity to earn above-average investment returnsover the intermediate-term is favorable. The investment environment is normalizing from the perspective of riskand reward since the possibility of a depression disappeared and equity pricesexperienced a spectacular rebound. Thelast 18 months were extraordinary as financial panic, high volatility and greatuncertainty created widespread fears of financial meltdown and depression.
Atthis juncture, risks to the outlook include both the possibility of anoverheating or struggling economy after our initial recovery phase. Thepolicy response would be different in each case, but the risks of achievingeconomic stability would increase. Also,there are risks that foreigners will buy fewer U.S. bonds which could hurt thedollar’s value and possibly cause interest rates to increase sooner thanadvisable for domestic policy. Massivedeleveraging of consumer and government balance sheets must occur over theintermediate-term which will suppress spending growth as balance sheets arerestored. Additional risks includeburdensome regulation, a
Today,the key question is whether the stock market can experience another favorablereturn in 2010. We believe it can basedupon an improving economy and earnings gains combined with low inflation andinterest rates, attractive valuations and improving investor confidence.
| Yearend 2008 | Yearend 2009 | Difference/ Change | |
| Fed Funds Rate (%) | .25 | .25 | |
| 10 Yr. Treasury Yield (%) | 2.25 | 3.85 | +160 bps |
| Inflation (CPI y/y % ch.) | .10 | 2.70 | +260 bps |
| Gold ($/oz). | 883 | 1095 | +24% |
| Oil ($/barrel) | 45 | 79 | +76% |
| Dollar per Euro | 1.34 | 1.43 | +7% |